Helpline: 0808 800 0303

Government warned not to repeat Work Capability Assessment mistakes

22 February 2012

MPs have warned the Government not to repeat the mistakes of the Work Capability Assessment (WCA) when introducing Personal Independence Payments (PIP) in 2013.

These conclusions come from a new report, published on Monday 20 February 2012 by the Work and Pensions Select Committee.

The report recommends that the PIP assessment takes into the account the needs of disabled people and those with long-term health conditions, like Parkinson's, to make sure they get the benefits they need.

We welcome this report, and we hope this will avoid people with Parkinson's having to undergo repeated and potentially stressful re-assessments.

The Government want PIP to replace Disability Living Allowance (DLA) for working-age claimants in 2013.

A welcome change

We welcome this report, in particular the recommendation that the frequency of reassessments should be flexible for certain groups.

We hope this will avoid people with Parkinson's having to undergo repeated and potentially stressful re-assessments, as many have with Employment and Support Allowance (ESA).

The report also recommends a more flexible approach to assessments, allowing claimants to describe the impact their disability or long-term health condition has on their day-to-day lives. This should help people with Parkinson's explain the complex and fluctuating nature of their condition.

At the moment the company who carries out the work capability assessments do not face a penalty if it is proved (by an appeal) their initial assessment was incorrect.

The committee have, therefore, recommended that whoever wins the contract to carry out PIP assessments should only be paid if they get them right first time.

What happens now?

This report comes at a time when the Government has the opportunity to take on the Committee's recommendations, as part of the ongoing PIP consultation. We will be making a submission to this consultation. 

We hope these recommendations will be taken into consideration and reflected in future Government policy. Then people with Parkinson's can get fairer assessments for these vital benefits and are able to receive the right financial support.

Find out more